32 Non-Candy Halloween Treats Kids Actually Want

Updated September 7, 2023

From spooky trinkets and toys to allergy-friendly snacks, parents are sharing the non-candy Halloween treats that have been the biggest hit with their trick-or-treaters over the years.

Depending on what fun Halloween activities you have planned, these also make great school favors, party game prizes or Halloween gifts for kids.

Have you given out any Halloween candy alternatives that your trick-or-treaters loved? Share your reviews below!

33 Recommendations

Sort/Filter :

Halloween Maze Puzzles

Sue Krawitz Tandoc said: Kids will love these cute little Halloween-themed maze puzzles as a fun treat on Halloween. Ideal for Trick or Treating or in a party goody bag!

Pencil Toppers

Lisa R said: Pencil toppers are a great cheap option to throw into a Halloween goody bag or hand out to trick or treaters. There are a ton of options to choose from: erasers, squishy stress relievers, fidget toys and more. Buy pumpkin or skull erasers in bulk if you want to stick to a Halloween theme or choose cute characters and fidget toys for something kids will want to play with all year.