44 Easter Egg Fillers That Aren't Junk (Parents Vote!)

We're collecting a big list of parent-submitted ideas for Easter egg fillers that aren't junk!

Egg hunts are high on the list of our favorite Easter activities, but they're notorious for cheap candy and plastic trinkets that go straight to the landfill. Let's share ideas for toys and gifts that are fun for repeat play, far beyond Easter morning.

Add your favorite Easter egg stuffers below, and check out our list of Easter basket gifts for more fun ideas!


 

    Washi Tape

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  A set of decorative washi tape in assorted patterns will come in handy for all sorts of DIY crafts, card making, decorating planners and journals, and more!

    Friendship Bracelet Embroidery Floss

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  A colorful assortment of embroidery floss will keep your kids busy making friendship bracelets for hours. A great rainy day activity for spring!

    Mini Stamp Set

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  These cute little wooden stamps are Easter egg fillers that aren't junk, and you can place the ink pad into the basket!

    Backpack Pins

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  Cool enamel pins are fun Easter egg fillers for tweens and teens, and they can be used to decorate backpacks, lunchboxes, jackets or hats.

    Handmade Glass Marbles

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Sue Krawitz Tandoc said:  My son loves playing with marbles and I have put these large glow in the dark handmade glass ones in his plastic Easter Eggs. They are unique and fun to play with, and he enjoyed getting them from the Easter Bunny! If your kids are older, smaller marbles work well, too. Just be sure your child is old enough to not put them in their mouth.

    Rocks, Minerals & Fossils

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  This is a fun assortment for kids who are interested in a rock collection, and it's perfect for separating into Easter eggs.

    Cheddar Bunnies

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  Sprinkle a few cheddar bunnies in each egg for a fun Easter treat for a toddler.

    Spiral Hair Ties

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  Any hair ties make perfect Easter egg stuffers, though these spiral ones are a fun little splurge!

    Musical Egg Shakers

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  My kids loved these musical shakers when they were little. They'd fit inside a larger egg, but since they already look exactly like a plastic Easter egg, there's really no need!

    Pacifiers

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  Pacifiers are practical Easter egg stuffers for babies if you want to include your little one in the fun!

    Blank Jigsaw Puzzle

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  For a spin on the Easter egg scavenger hunt idea, decorate and customize one of these blank puzzles with a clue leading the kids to find their Easter basket gifts (or the first in a series of clues). Separate the puzzle into individual eggs, and the kids will enjoy piecing the clue together after finding them all. This set also comes with a few extra blank puzzles, which are a fun addition to the Easter basket so each kid can customize their own!

    Marvel Die-Cast Metal Collectible Figures

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Alexandra F. said:  My kids love playing with these mini collectibles and they are just the right size to fit inside an Easter egg! We’re big Marvel fans in our family, but you can find similar metal figs as gifts for Minecraft fans, Star Wars, D&D and more. All of them fit in our larger eggs, and some even fit in the smaller ones.

    PLUS PLUS

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Kelly R. said:  These puzzle-shaped tiles can be pieced together to create cool mosaic creations. Their tiny size makes them perfect not only as Easter egg fillers, but also for bringing along as toys for road trips, vacations and restaurant visits.

    Shoe and Wristband Charms

    Rating 1
    Rating 2
    Rating 3
    Rating 4
    Rating 5

    Sue Krawitz Tandoc said:  Your kids will love decorating their shoes and wristbands with these fun charms that are the perfect size to hide in their Easter eggs. They are ideal for sandals, Crocs, water shoes and breathable sneakers along with wristbands. There are many different options for both boys and girls! The charms are lightweight, non-toxic and washable.

Primary photo:   Eren Li from Pexels

Upparent collects community-submitted recommendations and reviews, and any ideas that are shared reflect the opinions of individual contributors.